OSSLT Module 4: Opinion Essay Workshop
Take a clear, unambiguous stand on a debate prompt, map three distinct arguments using the Hamburger blueprint, stress-test your logic with an AI Devil's Advocate, and write a 400–500 word 5-paragraph opinion essay.
Step 1: Taking a Stand & Planning the 'Hamburger' Map
Your essay topic for this workshop is a classic Ontario high school debate:
Opinion Prompt: "Should high schools have a mandatory dress code?"
- Pick One Side Only (Yes or No): Do not write "It depends" or "There are pros and cons to both." Pick the side where you can think of the three clearest examples, even if you don't personally care about dress codes!
- Build Your Hamburger Outline in your Google Doc:
- Top Bun (Introduction): Your clear thesis statement + preview of your 3 reasons.
- Patty 1 (Body Paragraph 1): Reason #1 + a specific real-world example.
- Patty 2 (Body Paragraph 2): Reason #2 + a specific real-world example.
- Patty 3 (Body Paragraph 3): Reason #3 + a specific real-world example (and counter-argument rebuttal).
- Bottom Bun (Conclusion): Restate your thesis in fresh words and leave a strong closing thought.
Video Walkthrough: The 5-Paragraph Opinion Essay Blueprint
Watch Mr. Senyshyn explain why OSSLT markers give no bonus points for sitting on the fence, and how to map three distinct reasons into a 5-paragraph blueprint:
A classic trap is writing three body paragraphs that all repeat the exact same point in slightly different words (e.g., "Clothes are expensive", "Families can't afford uniforms", and "Dress codes cost too much money"). Give the marker three distinct angles, such as: (1) Financial cost for families, (2) Student self-expression and individuality, and (3) Wasted instructional time policing outfits.
Step 2: Playing 'Devil's Advocate' with AI
Before you write your full 400–500 word draft, let's pressure-test your three arguments so your body paragraphs are bulletproof.
- Open your AI assistant and paste this prompt:
"I am planning an OSSLT Opinion Essay arguing that high schools [SHOULD / SHOULD NOT] have a mandatory dress code. My three reasons are: [1. ..., 2. ..., 3. ...]. Act as a 'Devil's Advocate' and tell me the strongest counter-argument someone could make against each of my three points, so I can strengthen my evidence."
- Read the AI's pushback and upgrade your outline in your Google Doc by adding a concession & rebuttal (e.g., "While critics argue that dress codes reduce distractions, enforcing strict clothing rules actually pulls teachers away from instruction...").
- Take a screenshot of your AI Devil's Advocate chat and paste it at the bottom of your Google Doc as proof of your planning process!
Video Walkthrough: Counterarguments & The Devil's Advocate Move
Watch Mr. Senyshyn demonstrate the 'Granted... However... Therefore...' rhythm to acknowledge an opposing view and knock it down with specific proof:
Step 3: Writing & Polishing the 5-Paragraph Opinion Essay
Now write your full 400–500 word (5-paragraph) Opinion Essay in your Google Doc!
- Paragraph 1 (Introduction): Hook the reader, state your clear Yes/No position on mandatory dress codes, and list your three distinct reasons.
- Paragraphs 2, 3, and 4 (Three Body Paragraphs): Start each body paragraph with a clear transition word ("First,", "Furthermore,", "Finally," or "In addition,") and develop your reason using APE (Topic Sentence → Specific Example/Scenario → Explanation linking back to your thesis).
- Paragraph 5 (Conclusion): Begin with a concluding transition ("In conclusion," or "Ultimately,"), summarize your three arguments without copy-pasting sentence for sentence, and end with a decisive final call to action.
Want extra timed practice or automated scoring on opinion essays? Launch the OSSLT Opinion Essay Practice Portal below!
OSSLT Opinion Essay Practice & AI Scoring Portal
Practice additional OSSLT opinion prompts with a live word-count gauge and instant Code 10–60 rubric feedback.
What to Turn In (Module Deliverables) ▼
-
Google Doc containing:
- Your outline or "Hamburger Map" of arguments
- The full Opinion Essay (approx. 400-500 words)
- A screenshot of your AI "Devil's Advocate" chat session
Learning Goals & Success Criteria ▼
Learning Goals (We are learning to):
-
Develop a clear position on a prompt and support it with three distinct reasons
-
Organize ideas into a coherent multi-paragraph essay with a clear beginning, middle, and end
-
Evaluate arguments for logical consistency and strength using AI feedback
Success Criteria (I can):
-
formulate a clear opinion and support it with relevant and sufficient evidence
Expectations: W1.1, W1.2, W1.3 -
organize my ideas into a logical sequence using effective transition words
Expectations: W1.5, W2.1, W2.4 -
refine my writing to ensure my voice is persuasive and my grammar follows Canadian conventions
Expectations: W2.6, W3.1, W3.4
Evaluation Rubric (4-Level Achievement Chart) ▼
| Category | Level 4 (80–100%) | Level 3 (70–79%) | Level 2 (60–69%) | Level 1 (50–59%) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
|
Knowledge/Understanding
How well does the student demonstrate an understanding of the opinion essay structure (intro, body, conclusion)?
|
Demonstrates thorough knowledge of essay structure and persuasive forms | Demonstrates considerable knowledge of essay structure | Demonstrates some knowledge of essay structure | Demonstrates limited knowledge of essay structure |
|
Thinking/Inquiring
How effectively does the student develop and support their arguments with logical evidence?
|
Arguments are insightful, highly logical, and supported by compelling evidence | Arguments are clear and supported by considerable evidence | Arguments are general and supported by some evidence | Arguments are weak or lack sufficient evidence |
|
Application
How well does the student use AI to identify weaknesses in their argument and make improvements?
|
Uses AI feedback with a high degree of effectiveness to significantly strengthen the essay | Uses AI feedback with considerable effectiveness | Uses AI feedback with some effectiveness | Uses AI feedback with limited effectiveness |
|
Communication
How effectively does the student use transitions and Canadian spelling to ensure a smooth flow of ideas?
|
Communicates with a high degree of clarity; flow is seamless and spelling is accurate | Communicates with considerable clarity and flow | Communicates with some clarity; flow may be disjointed in places | Communicates with limited clarity |
Knowledge/Understanding ▼
Demonstrates thorough knowledge of essay structure and persuasive forms
Demonstrates considerable knowledge of essay structure
Demonstrates some knowledge of essay structure
Demonstrates limited knowledge of essay structure
Thinking/Inquiring ▼
Arguments are insightful, highly logical, and supported by compelling evidence
Arguments are clear and supported by considerable evidence
Arguments are general and supported by some evidence
Arguments are weak or lack sufficient evidence
Application ▼
Uses AI feedback with a high degree of effectiveness to significantly strengthen the essay
Uses AI feedback with considerable effectiveness
Uses AI feedback with some effectiveness
Uses AI feedback with limited effectiveness
Communication ▼
Communicates with a high degree of clarity; flow is seamless and spelling is accurate
Communicates with considerable clarity and flow
Communicates with some clarity; flow may be disjointed in places
Communicates with limited clarity